22 Best Non-Profit Nursing Homes in Indiana

Nurse hours

9.62 /day

Staff turnover

17%

Serious cites

0

St. Augustine Home for the Aged is a small nonprofit home in Indianapolis, just 23 certified beds, and its recent inspection history is mostly clean where it counts: 13 deficiencies on record, none of them causing harm or jeopardy, with the last survey completed in July 2025. Two abuse-related citations are worth asking about directly, since those tend to say more about staffing and supervision than paperwork does. The quality measure side is strong, and inspection results sit above average. Where this home gives ground is staffing, which is what holds its overall standing back despite solid clinical numbers. Ask about direct care hours per resident on evenings and weekends.

Nurse hours

4.43 /day

Staff turnover

24%

Serious cites

0

Marquette runs on a non-profit model with 57 beds in Indianapolis, and the staffing numbers stand out first: 4.43 nurse hours per resident day, roughly 15% above the national average, with weekend coverage dipping about 13% below its own weekday level. Turnover sits at 23.7% against a national average near 46%, meaning the people caring for residents tend to stay. The tradeoff is a longer deficiency record, 15 citations on file, two serious enough to reach harm or jeopardy level, though none involve abuse. The most recent inspection was February 2026. Steady staffing and strong quality marks don't erase those two serious findings; they just tell you where to focus your questions.

Nurse hours

5.00 /day

Staff turnover

20%

Serious cites

0

Four Seasons runs about 5 hours of nursing care per resident per day, roughly 30% above the national average, and weekend coverage dips only about 13% from its own weekday level, a modest drop, not a staffing cliff. Staff turnover sits at 20%, well under the national 45.8%, which matters for residents who need consistent faces. The home carries 8 deficiencies on its current record, none at the harm level and none tied to abuse, with its most recent inspection dated June 2025. It's a small nonprofit, 30 beds, so read those numbers as a snapshot of a stable, well-staffed operation rather than a guarantee about what any single week feels like.

Nurse hours

5.23 /day

Staff turnover

28%

Serious cites

0

Towne House in Fort Wayne runs on a nonprofit model with 32 certified beds, and the staffing numbers stand out right away: 5.23 nurse hours per resident per day, roughly a third more than the national average of 3.86. Weekend coverage dips about 14% below its own weekday level, worth asking about if your family visits mainly on Saturdays or Sundays. Staff turnover sits at 27.8% against a national average near 46%, which suggests people tend to stay. The inspection record is clean where it matters, five deficiencies total, none at the harm or jeopardy level, none abuse-related, and the most recent inspection was in May 2026. Quality measures score well too, and the health inspection side is as strong as it gets.

Nurse hours

4.39 /day

Staff turnover

32%

Serious cites

0

Swiss Village runs 4.39 nurse hours per resident day, about 14 percent above the national average, and its staff turnover of 32.4 percent sits well under the 45.8 percent national figure, that combination is harder to find than it should be. Weekend staffing drops roughly 12 percent below weekday levels, so ask how that plays out on a Sunday. Five deficiencies are on record, none at the harm level, though one is abuse-related, and the most recent inspection was December 2025. As a nonprofit with 128 beds, it has the staffing depth and consistency that show up in the numbers.

Nurse hours

4.35 /day

Staff turnover

34%

Serious cites

0

Westminster Village Muncie is a 76-bed nonprofit home, and the numbers behind it are steady. Nurse staffing runs 4.35 hours per resident day, about 13% above the national average, with weekend coverage dipping roughly 8% below its own weekday level, normal, but worth asking about. Staff turnover sits at 34.2% against a national average near 46%, which suggests people tend to stay. The inspection record shows 11 deficiencies, none at the harm level and none abuse-related, with the most recent inspection in May 2026. For a family weighing options, this reads as a well-staffed, stable nonprofit with a clean serious-deficiency record.

Nurse hours

7.02 /day

Staff turnover

39%

Serious cites

0

University Place in West Lafayette runs a small 30-bed home with church-affiliated nonprofit ownership, and its staffing numbers stand out. At 7.02 nurse hours per resident day, it's roughly 82% above the national average of 3.86, more than double the typical direct care. Turnover sits at 39.3%, below the 45.8% national figure, and weekend staffing dips only about 5% from weekdays, which is a mild drop. The trade-off is the inspection record: 20 deficiencies, one at the harm level, with a 3-star health inspection rating. The most recent inspection was in November 2025. Quality measures rate 4 stars. You're getting a well-staffed home with a longer-than-ideal deficiency list, though nothing abuse-related.

Nurse hours

4.27 /day

Staff turnover

32%

Serious cites

0

Hubbard Hill Estates runs a tight ship on the numbers that matter most. Nurse staffing sits at 4.27 hours per resident day, about 11% above the national average, and weekend coverage stays reasonably close to weekday levels even though it dips roughly 14%. Staff turnover of 31.5% is well below the national 45.8%, which suggests people stick around, a good sign for residents who value consistent caregivers. The inspection record backs that up: five total deficiencies on file, none at the harm or jeopardy level and none abuse-related, with the most recent state visit in December 2025. For a 66-bed nonprofit in Elkhart, that combination of low turnover, solid staffing, and a clean complaint history is what a family should be looking for.

Nurse hours

4.89 /day

Staff turnover

36%

Serious cites

0

Holy Cross Village runs nurse staffing at 4.89 hours per resident day, roughly 27% above the national average, and its staff turnover of 35.5% sits well below the 45.8% national figure, a sign people tend to stay. The tradeoff is the inspection record: 14 deficiencies, including one at the harm or jeopardy level and one abuse-related, with a 3-out-of-5 health inspection rating, though the most recent inspection was May 2026. Weekend staffing dips about 8% below weekday levels, worth asking about if your family visits Saturdays or Sundays. The quality measure rating comes in at 4 out of 5. Strong everyday staffing and steady retention, but the harm-level and abuse-related citations deserve a direct question before you decide.

Nurse hours

9.69 /day

Staff turnover

n/a

Serious cites

0

The Barrington of Carmel is an eight-bed nonprofit home, which is small even by the standards of Indiana's residential care. Its nurse staffing works out to 9.69 hours per resident day, roughly two and a half times the national average, though weekend coverage drops about 23% below what the home provides on weekdays. State inspectors visited in September 2025 and logged four deficiencies, none involving harm or jeopardy and none related to abuse. The home's last inspection was recent enough that its record reflects current conditions rather than old problems. With that staffing cushion and a clean harm history, the main thing to watch is whether weekend care holds up.

Nurse hours

4.35 /day

Staff turnover

43%

Serious cites

0

Greencroft Healthcare runs 214 certified beds in Goshen as a nonprofit, and the staffing picture is genuinely solid: 4.35 nursing hours per resident day, roughly 13% above the national average, with weekend coverage only about 7% lighter than weekdays. Turnover sits at 42.8%, a bit better than the 45.8% national figure. The trouble is inspections. A 1-out-of-5 health inspection rating, 38 deficiencies on the current record, including three at harm or jeopardy level and three tied to abuse, with the last survey dated May 2025. Strong staffing and a 5-out-of-5 quality measure score don't erase that citation history, ask pointed questions about the harm-level findings and what changed since.

Nurse hours

4.41 /day

Staff turnover

41%

Serious cites

0

Lutheran Life Villages runs 84 certified beds as a nonprofit, and the numbers hold up well. Nurse staffing sits at 4.41 hours per resident day, roughly 14% above the national average of 3.86, though weekend coverage dips about 9% below what the home provides on weekdays, so ask how that gap gets managed. Staff turnover is 41.4%, a bit better than the 45.8% national figure, which matters for continuity of care. Seven deficiencies on the current record, none at the harm or jeopardy level and none abuse-related, with a recent inspection in March 2026. Quality and inspection ratings both came back at the top of CMS's scale.

Nurse hours

5.47 /day

Staff turnover

39%

Serious cites

0

Westminster Village runs one of the better staffing operations you'll find in Indiana, 5.47 nurse hours per resident day, well above the national average, and weekend coverage only dips about 6% below weekdays, which matters because that's where a lot of homes cut corners. Turnover sits at 39.3%, better than the national rate. The trouble is the inspection record: 15 deficiencies, one serious enough to cause harm, and a $72,545 fine. A recent January 2026 inspection means that record is fresh, not stale. Strong hands-on care, but a survey history that suggests problems with how care gets delivered and documented. Worth asking the administrator directly about that harm-level finding before you decide.

Nurse hours

3.96 /day

Staff turnover

28%

Serious cites

0

Good Samaritan in Oakland City runs on a nonprofit model with 103 certified beds, and the staffing picture is genuinely solid, 3.96 nurse hours per resident day puts it modestly above the national average of 3.86. Weekend coverage dips about 12% from weekday levels, which is common but worth knowing if you're visiting on a Saturday. What stands out most is retention: 27.5% annual turnover against a national average of 45.8% suggests people stay here, and that continuity matters for residents who need consistent caregivers. Nine deficiencies on record with none at harm or jeopardy level and none abuse-related, plus a recent March 2026 inspection, is a relatively clean sheet. The quality measure score of 5/5 reinforces that the clinical outcomes are tracking well.

Nurse hours

4.08 /day

Staff turnover

33%

Serious cites

0

Lutheran Life Villages runs about 4.08 nurse hours per resident per day, roughly 6% above the national average, and its staff retention is stronger than most, 33% turnover against a national 45.8%. Weekend coverage dips about 9% below weekday levels, so ask how that plays out on Sundays and holidays. The 11 deficiencies on record include three tied to abuse, though none rose to harm or jeopardy, and the most recent inspection was August 2025. Quality measures score well; the health inspection side is more mixed. As a nonprofit, it answers to a board rather than shareholders, which tends to shape how it spends on direct care.

Nurse hours

4.96 /day

Staff turnover

47%

Serious cites

0

Lutheran Community Home runs on a nonprofit model with 95 certified beds in Seymour, and its staffing is the clearest strength here, 4.96 nurse hours per resident day, roughly 28% above the national average of 3.86. That shows up in its five-star staffing rating. Weekend coverage dips about 11% below weekday levels, though, so care may look different on a Saturday. Turnover sits at 47.4%, just above the national 45.8%, meaning aides and nurses still cycle through. Its inspection record shows 13 deficiencies, none at the harm or jeopardy level and none abuse-related, with a recent survey in December 2025. Quality measures land at three stars, softer than the staffing story.

Nurse hours

5.79 /day

Staff turnover

47%

Serious cites

0

Asbury Towers runs a nonprofit home with 48 beds in Greencastle, and its nurse staffing sits at 5.79 hours per resident day, roughly half again the national average of 3.86. That's the number driving its record. Weekend coverage dips about 15% below its own weekday level, and turnover is 46.7%, a touch above the 45.8% national figure, so the staffing edge comes with some churn behind it. The health inspection side holds up: a 4-out-of-5 rating, last surveyed March 30, 2026, with 15 deficiencies on file but none at the harm or jeopardy level and nothing abuse-related. Fifteen citations is not a spotless record, though the absence of serious harm matters more than the raw count.

Nurse hours

4.99 /day

Staff turnover

48%

Serious cites

0

Elwood Health and Living runs on a nonprofit model with 85 beds, and its nurse staffing sits at 4.99 hours per resident per day, roughly 29% above the national average of 3.86. Weekend coverage dips about 7% below its own weekday levels, and annual turnover is 48%, slightly above the 45.8% national figure. The inspection record is where things get uneven: 23 deficiencies on file, none at the harm or jeopardy level, but three tied to abuse. The health inspection rating lands at 2 out of 5, while quality measures hit 5 out of 5 and staffing earns 4. The last inspection was March 12, 2026, so the record is current rather than stale. Strong daily staffing and quality scores coexist with inspection problems worth asking about directly.

Nurse hours

4.40 /day

Staff turnover

43%

Serious cites

0

Bertha D Garten Ketcham Memorial Center runs on 4.40 nurse hours per resident per day, roughly 14% above the national average of 3.86, that's the strongest thing in its numbers. Weekend coverage drops about 13% below its own weekday level, so if you're visiting on a Saturday, expect a thinner floor. Staff turnover is 42.6%, a bit better than the 45.8% national rate. Against that, the current record carries 18 deficiencies, including one at the harm level and one abuse-related, and its last inspection was January 2026. The staffing and quality stars come in at 4 out of 5, inspection at 3.

Nurse hours

4.00 /day

Staff turnover

43%

Serious cites

0

Greenwood Village South runs on 4.00 nurse hours per resident day, a bit above the national average, though weekends drop roughly 9% below its own weekday level, worth knowing if your visits tend to fall on Saturdays or Sundays. Staff turnover sits at 43.1%, slightly better than the national figure, and the home carries six deficiencies with none at the harm level and nothing abuse-related. A July 2025 inspection means the record is recent, and a nonprofit corporation owns its 137 beds. The staffing star comes in lower than the inspection and quality marks, which is the one number here I'd ask about directly.