★★★★☆CMS 4/595 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
- Nurse hours
- 4.60 /day
- Staff turnover
- 32%
- Serious cites
- 0
Good Shepherd Home runs on 4.60 nurse hours per resident day, about 19% more than the national average, and its staff turnover of 32% sits well under the 45.8% national figure, both signs of a stable, adequately covered floor. The trade-offs show up elsewhere: weekend staffing drops roughly 16% below its own weekday level, and the current record carries 30 deficiencies, one serious enough to reach harm or jeopardy, though none involve abuse. Inspectors last visited in October 2024. Quality measures score high, staffing solid, inspections middling, a home that's generally well-run with at least one lapse worth asking about directly.
★★★☆☆CMS 3/556 bedsFor-profitMedicaid
- Nurse hours
- 3.48 /day
- Staff turnover
- 37%
- Serious cites
- 0
St. Catherine's runs leaner on nurse hours than most homes, 3.48 per resident day against a national average of 3.86, and weekends get thinner still, dropping roughly 18% below its own weekday staffing. Turnover sits at 36.6%, which is actually better than the 45.8% national figure, so the people who stay seem to stay. The inspection record is more mixed: 22 deficiencies, including one at the harm level and two tied to abuse, plus a $14,433 fine, though the most recent inspection was in March 2026 and the quality measures score well. It's a for-profit corporate home with 56 beds.
★★★★☆CMS 4/550 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
- Nurse hours
- 3.50 /day
- Staff turnover
- 63%
- Serious cites
- 0
Independence House is a 50-bed nonprofit home in Fostoria, and its inspection record is the strongest thing it has going: 11 deficiencies on file, none of them causing harm or jeopardy, with the last state visit in September 2024. Where it gives ground is staffing. At 3.50 nurse hours per resident day, it runs about 9% under the national average of 3.86, and weekends dip roughly 13% below its own weekday coverage, worth asking about directly if your family member needs help most on Saturdays and Sundays. Turnover sits at 63.3% against a national 45.8%, so expect some churn among the aides providing daily care.