69/100
Average
Mcgivney Health Care Center
2907 East Smoky Row, Carmel, IN 46033
- Certified beds
- 37
- Occupancy
- 92%
- Ownership
- Non-profit
- Accepts
- Medicare + Medicaid
What to ask about before you visit
These are findings in the public CMS record for this home. They are not our opinion, each one comes straight from a federal inspection or enforcement file.
$8,189 in federal fines
CMS has fined this facility across 1 penalty action(s).
Our read on Mcgivney Health Care Center
Mcgivney Health Care Center runs on 2.91 nursing hours per resident per day, roughly a quarter below the national average, which is the main reason its staffing rating sits at the bottom of the federal scale. The tradeoff is a workforce that largely stays put: 20% annual turnover against a national rate of 45.8%, and weekend coverage holds level with weekdays rather than dropping off. The record cuts both ways, 43 deficiencies, including one at the harm level and two tied to abuse, with an $8,189 fine, but the most recent inspection came in August 2025, so the picture is current. At 37 beds, this is a small nonprofit where the same aides likely know every resident by name.
Written from the CMS figures for this home shown further down this page. Nothing here is paid for or supplied by the home.
How this grade was calculated
Every point is shown. Nothing is weighted behind the scenes, the full formula is on How we grade.
A full pentagon is full marks. The shape shows what kind of good or bad a home is, two homes can share a score and look nothing alike.
Inspection safety
30/30Citations from state health inspections over the last three surveys, weighted by how much harm CMS says they caused.
- →No citations recorded in the last 3 years
Staffing
9/30Nursing hours per resident per day, adjusted for how sick the residents are, plus RN cover and weekend consistency.
- →2.98 total nurse hours per resident per day (national median 3.77)
- →0.13 RN hours per resident per day
- →Weekend staffing holds steady
Staff stability
15/15How much of the nursing team leaves in a year. High turnover means a resident rarely sees the same face twice.
- →20% of nursing staff left in the last year
Resident outcomes
9/15The CMS quality-measure rating, built from resident outcomes like falls, pressure ulcers, infections and antipsychotic use.
- →3 of 5 stars on the CMS quality-measure rating
Enforcement history
6/10Fines and payment denials CMS has imposed. A denial of payment means CMS stopped paying for new admissions.
- →$8,189 in federal fines across 1 action(s)
- →-2 for 1 denial(s) of Medicare payment for new admissions
Staffing, against the national average
Full detailHours of nursing care each resident receives per day. The marker on each bar is the national average.
RNs are the licence level most likely to catch a resident deteriorating.
The shift most families visit, and the one thinned first.
The share of nursing staff who left over the last year.
Recent inspection findings
Last standard health inspection: August 26, 2025 (1 year ago). No citations were recorded.
No health-inspection citations on record for this facility in the current CMS release.
Who owns this home
Full recordPart of WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, which operates 5 homes. Staffing budgets are usually set at chain level, not in the building.
What families say
Write a reviewNo family reviews yet for Mcgivney Health Care Center. If you or a relative have experience of this home, other families would find it useful.
Be the first to reviewEvery review is confirmed by email and read by a moderator before it appears. We remove reviews written by or for a facility. If something is wrong right now, report a concern , that routes you to your state ombudsman, who can actually intervene.
Common questions about Mcgivney Health Care Center
What is the ElderGrade for Mcgivney Health Care Center? +
Mcgivney Health Care Center holds an ElderGrade of C (69 out of 100), which we describe as "average". The grade combines its inspection citations, nurse staffing levels, staff turnover, resident outcomes and enforcement history from the federal CMS record.
How many nursing hours does each resident get at Mcgivney Health Care Center? +
Residents receive an average of 2.91 nursing hours per day across all nursing staff, against a national average of 3.86 hours.
Has Mcgivney Health Care Center been cited for harming residents? +
No. None of the 0 citations on record were scored at the levels CMS uses to indicate actual harm or immediate jeopardy.
Does Mcgivney Health Care Center accept Medicaid? +
Yes, Mcgivney Health Care Center is certified to accept Medicaid, which is the programme that pays for long-term custodial care once a resident meets their state's income and asset limits.
- Add another