ElderGrade Check a home before you move a parent in Compare
Nursing homes Best graded Watchlist Home health Hospice Costs Medicaid Guides How we grade Ownership Compare homes

46 Best Non-Profit Nursing Homes in Ohio

46 of the 922 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Ohio (5%) are top-graded non-profit, and all are listed below. 46 of the 46 graded homes earn an A and 0 earn a D or F. They average 5.12 nursing hours per resident per day, 1.43 hours above the 3.69 for every home in Ohio. Deupree Cottages in Cincinnati grades highest at A (99 out of 100).

How top-graded non-profit homes in Ohio compare

This group set against every nursing home in Ohio, from the current CMS release.

Nursing hours per resident per day

5.12

All homes in Ohio: 3.69

Better than the local average

Nurse staff turnover

39.5%

All homes in Ohio: 48.7%

Better than the local average

Average ElderGrade score

90.3/100

All homes in Ohio: 72.9/100

Better than the local average

Grade spread

A

46 grade A,

The best-graded top-graded non-profit home in Ohio is Deupree Cottages in Cincinnati, OH, grade A, 99/100.

Every top-graded non-profit nursing home in Ohio

Showing 41 to 46 of 46, best-graded first.

A

86/100

Mt Healthy Christian Home

Cincinnati, OH · Hamilton County

CMS 5/575 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.99 /day
Staff turnover
51%
Serious cites
0

Mt Healthy Christian Home runs on unusually heavy staffing for a 75-bed nonprofit, just under 5 nurse hours per resident per day, roughly 29% above the national average, and weekend coverage barely dips below weekdays. That's the kind of consistency that matters when a resident needs help on a Sunday night. Inspections back it up: a perfect health inspection record and no abuse deficiencies, with the most recent visit in October 2024. Two things keep this from being a clean sweep. Staff turnover sits at 51.4%, above the 45.8% national average, which can wear on continuity of care. And of seven deficiencies on record, one rose to the harm level. Worth asking the administrator how they're addressing both.

A

86/100

Western Reserve Masonic Comm

Medina, OH · Medina County

CMS 5/550 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.48 /day
Staff turnover
51%
Serious cites
0

Western Reserve Masonic Comm runs 4.48 nurse hours per resident day, about 16% above the national average, and weekends dip roughly 10% below its own weekday staffing. Turnover sits at 50.7%, higher than the 45.8% national figure. The current record shows six deficiencies, none at the harm or jeopardy level, though three are abuse-related, and two fines totaling $8,090. The last inspection was May 30, 2025, and CMS gives it five stars on health inspections and quality measures, four on staffing. Staffing depth and inspection results are strong here; the turnover rate and those three abuse-related tags are the things worth asking about directly.

A

85.5/100

Shepherd Of The Valley Poland

Poland, OH · Mahoning County

CMS 5/532 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.53 /day
Staff turnover
26%
Serious cites
0

Shepherd of the Valley Poland runs on church-affiliated nonprofit ownership and 32 certified beds, and the numbers mostly back it up. Nurse staffing sits at 4.53 hours per resident day, roughly 17% above the national average, and turnover is 25.8% against a national figure near 46%, that kind of retention matters more than almost anything else for consistent care. The tradeoff is weekends, when coverage drops about 22% below the home's own weekday level, and the inspection record shows 7 deficiencies, one serious enough to reach harm or jeopardy, with no abuse citations. The last inspection was recent, in September 2025. Nothing here looks like a crisis, but that one harm-level finding and the weekend dip are worth asking about directly.

A

85/100

Altenheim

Strongsville, OH · Cuyahoga County

CMS 4/5128 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.75 /day
Staff turnover
40%
Serious cites
0

Altenheim runs on 4.75 nurse hours per resident day, about 23% above the national average, and weekend staffing dips roughly 13% from its own weekday level, so coverage is thinner on Saturdays and Sundays than the weekday numbers suggest. Staff turnover sits at 40%, a bit better than the 45.8% national figure. The health inspection record shows 12 deficiencies, one of them at the harm or jeopardy level, with no abuse citations, and the last inspection was July 2024. Quality measures score 5 out of 5 while inspection results sit at 3, a split worth noticing: the day-to-day care metrics look strong, but the survey history carries one serious finding.

A

85/100

Bethany Village

Dayton, OH · Montgomery County

CMS 5/5227 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.23 /day
Staff turnover
36%
Serious cites
0

Bethany Village runs on 4.23 nursing hours per resident day, roughly 9% above the national average, though weekends drop about 12% below its own weekday staffing. That gap matters more than the headline number if your family visits on Saturdays and Sundays. Staff turnover sits at 35.8%, well under the 45.8% national figure, which suggests people tend to stay. The inspection record is thin: two deficiencies total, none at the harm level, none abuse-related, with a survey completed in January 2026. As a nonprofit with 227 beds, it carries five stars on both health inspections and quality measures.

A

85/100

Mennonite Memorial Home

Bluffton, OH · Allen County

CMS 3/560 bedsNon-profitMedicaid
Nurse hours
4.02 /day
Staff turnover
47%
Serious cites
0

Mennonite Memorial Home runs on slightly better staffing than most places, about 4.02 nurse hours per resident day against a national average of 3.86, with a four-star staffing rating to match. The catch is weekends, when coverage drops roughly 11% below what the home staffs on weekdays, and turnover sits at 46.8%, a touch above the national rate. Its inspection record shows 29 deficiencies, none at the harm or jeopardy level, though four are abuse-related, and the most recent inspection was in late 2024. The quality measure rating of four stars suggests the clinical numbers hold up. Church-affiliated nonprofit ownership, 60 beds.

Frequently asked questions

How many top-graded non-profit nursing homes are there in Ohio?
There are 46 top-graded non-profit Medicare-certified nursing homes in Ohio, 5% of the 922 nursing homes there.
Are top-graded non-profit nursing homes better staffed?
In Ohio they average 5.12 total nursing hours per resident per day, against 3.69 for all nursing homes in Ohio, a difference of +1.43 hours. Staff turnover averages 39.5% against 48.7%.
Which top-graded non-profit nursing home grades best in Ohio?
Deupree Cottages in Cincinnati, OH, grade A, 99 out of 100.
Does being top-graded non-profit mean a nursing home is safe?
No. Of the 46 graded top-graded non-profit homes in Ohio, 46 grade A and 0 grade D or F.
Do top-graded non-profit nursing homes in Ohio accept Medicaid?
45 of the 46 are certified to accept Medicaid. See Medicaid and nursing homes.

Before you shortlist in Ohio