All 3 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Geneseo,
side by side on the things that separate them: how many nursing hours each resident gets, how much of the
staff leaves each year, and what inspectors found on their last visit.
Hillcrest Home is owned by the city or county, which usually means steadier oversight and no corporate parent pushing for cuts. The tradeoff shows up in the numbers: nurses give 3.27 hours per resident per day, about 15% under the national average, and weekends run roughly 15% lighter than weekdays. Staff turnover sits at 60.9% against a national 45.8%, so familiar faces are hard to count on. Inspections are the strong point, a 4/5 health inspection rating with a recent May 2025 visit, but the record still carries 17 deficiencies, one at harm level and two abuse-related, which is worth asking about directly.
Allure of Geneseo runs lean on nurse staffing at 3.37 hours per resident day, about 13 percent under the national average, and weekends drop roughly another 10 percent below its own weekday level. Turnover sits at 25 percent, well under the national 45.8 percent, so the aides and nurses who are there tend to stay. Inspections tell a mixed story: 22 deficiencies on record, including one at the harm level and one abuse-related, though the most recent visit was January 2026 and the health inspection and quality measure ratings both came in at 4 out of 5. The staffing rating is 2 out of 5. For-profit, limited liability ownership.
Hammond-Henry runs a tight ship on staffing, 3.76 nurse hours per resident day, close to the national mark, and turnover at 40% actually beats the typical 45.8%. The catch is weekends, when coverage drops about 11% below weekday levels, and a health inspection record that's harder to defend: eight deficiencies, including two at harm or jeopardy level and two tied to abuse, plus a $75,020 fine. That September 2024 inspection is recent enough to still carry weight. The quality and staffing scores look strong on paper, but the survey history is where the real risk sits. For a 38-bed home, that's a lot of regulatory attention. Ask about weekend coverage and what changed since last fall.